Advance Care Directive vs Enduring Guardian in NSW: What’s the Difference and Do You Need Both?

In short

An Advance Care Directive records your own wishes about future healthcare and treatment. An Enduring Guardian is a person you appoint to make selected health, lifestyle and accommodation decisions for you if you cannot make those decisions yourself.

They are not competing documents. They answer different questions:

  • an Advance Care Directive says what you would want; and
  • an Enduring Guardian provides a person who can make an authorised decision when you cannot.

Many people choose both because a clear directive gives guidance while a trusted Enduring Guardian can respond to circumstances that the document could not predict.

What is an Advance Care Directive in NSW?

An Advance Care Directive (ACD) is a record of your preferences, values and instructions about healthcare and treatment if you later cannot make or communicate a decision. It might address treatments you would accept or refuse, what quality of life means to you, or who should be consulted about your care.

In practice, a detailed written directive, made while you have decision-making capacity, is usually easier for doctors, family and the person responsible for your care to identify and apply.

An ACD is about your wishes. It does not appoint somebody to control your bank account, sign contracts or change your Will.

What does an Enduring Guardian do?

An Enduring Guardian is someone you legally appoint to make the types of personal decisions you select if you lose the capacity to make them yourself. Depending on the appointment, the role may include decisions about:

  • where you live and what support or services you receive;
  • healthcare, medical and dental treatment; and
  • other functions authorised by the appointment.

The appointment operates during your lifetime. It is not an executor appointment and it does not give the person authority to distribute your estate after your death.

An Enduring Guardian also does not make financial decisions. For those decisions, you may need an Enduring Power of Attorney. The same person may be suitable for more than one role, but the documents should be considered separately.

When does each document operate?

You continue to make your own decisions while you have capacity. An Enduring Guardian does not take over merely because the appointment has been signed. The NSW Government explains that the Enduring Guardian’s authority begins when you are unable to make decisions for yourself and ends if you regain that capacity.

Healthcare professionals use an ACD when you are unable to make or communicate decisions about your treatment. The directive therefore provides the starting point for understanding your wishes. Your Enduring Guardian, if appointed with the relevant functions, can make an authorised decision in the situation that arises.

The timing can be important. A person may lose capacity temporarily after an accident, or permanently after illness. This is a lifetime incapacity issue, not an estate-administration issue.

How do an Advance Care Directive and Enduring Guardian work together?

Suppose you have written that you would not want a particular treatment in a specified medical situation. You later cannot communicate, and your Enduring Guardian is asked to participate in decisions. The Guardian should know about the directive and healthcare professionals should have access to it. The directive explains your preferences; the Guardian is the person with the legal role to make decisions within the appointment.

The documents should not contradict each other. Tell the person you appoint that the ACD exists, give them a copy and identify where the original is kept. Give a copy to your usual doctor or treating team where appropriate. Review the directive if your diagnosis, values, treatment preferences or relationships change.

An Enduring Guardian cannot make or change your ACD or your Will for you. That is why making the documents while you have capacity matters.

Do you need both?

There is no universal answer. An ACD may be especially useful if you have clear treatment preferences or want to guide a decision-maker through a difficult situation. An Enduring Guardian may be especially useful if you want to choose who will make personal decisions rather than leave the decision to the default person-responsible hierarchy or a later guardianship process.

Having both may be sensible where:

  • you want your own wishes recorded but recognise that treatment decisions can involve facts you cannot predict;
  • you have a trusted person who understands your values and can speak with doctors;
  • you want to nominate somebody for lifestyle or accommodation decisions as well as treatment decisions; or
  • your family structure is complicated and you want to reduce uncertainty about who should be consulted.

You may choose different people for different roles. The right choice depends on trust, availability, values, communication skills and the functions actually needed. An Enduring Guardian should be willing to take on a demanding role and should know how to find your ACD.

What else should form part of the plan?

An ACD and Enduring Guardian do not replace a Will or an Enduring Power of Attorney. A complete NSW plan commonly considers:

  • a Will for assets and executor decisions after death;
  • an Enduring Power of Attorney for financial and legal decisions during life;
  • an Enduring Guardian appointment for selected personal decisions during life; and
  • an ACD for your healthcare wishes.

The documents should be reviewed together after marriage, separation, a serious diagnosis, a move interstate or overseas, a change in assets, or a change in the people you trust.

What should you do next?

Start by writing down the decisions that matter to you and the people who should know your wishes. Do not assume that a family member will automatically have the authority you expect. Ask whether the proposed Guardian is willing to act, confirm the functions you want to appoint, and make sure the ACD is specific enough to be useful without trying to predict every medical scenario.

For help coordinating these documents, see BizLawyers’ services for advanced healthcare directives, enduring guardianship, powers of attorney and Wills and estate planning.

Primary sources

Sources checked 5 October 2026.

Need help with your NSW planning documents?

If you are reviewing an Advance Care Directive, Enduring Guardian appointment, Power of Attorney or Will, contact BizLawyers or call 1800 893 836.

This article provides general information only and is not legal or medical advice. The appropriate documents and instructions depend on your capacity, health, relationships, assets and the law applying to your circumstances.

Back to Legal Guides

Linked Associations

Law SocietyPEXA